What Is Bird in Hand?
Let me explain the bird in hand theory directly to you: it's a financial concept that suggests investors like you and me prefer receiving dividends from stocks rather than betting on potential capital gains, mainly because capital gains come with a lot of uncertainty. Drawing from the old saying 'a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush,' this theory emphasizes that the sure thing of dividend payments is more appealing than the chance of bigger gains down the line.
Key Takeaways
- The bird-in-hand theory asserts that investors favor stock dividends over potential capital gains due to the inherent uncertainty in gains.
- It serves as a counterargument to the Modigliani-Miller dividend irrelevance theory, which claims investors don't care about the source of their returns.
- Capital gains investing embodies the 'two in the bush' part of the adage, representing higher but riskier potential rewards.
Understanding Bird in Hand
You should know that Myron Gordon and John Lintner created the bird-in-hand theory to challenge the Modigliani-Miller dividend irrelevance theory. That earlier theory says investors don't mind if their stock returns come from dividends or capital gains. But under bird-in-hand, I see that stocks with strong dividend payouts attract investors like you, which drives up their market prices. If you believe in this theory, you'll view dividends as more reliable than capital gains.
Bird in Hand vs. Capital Gains Investing
When you invest for capital gains, you're basically speculating. You might do thorough research on companies, markets, and the economy to get an edge, but stock performance depends on unpredictable factors beyond your control. That's why capital gains are the 'two in the bush'—they could be substantial, but they might also be zero or even losses.
Look at broad indices like the Dow Jones Industrial Average or S&P 500; they've averaged about 10% annual returns over time. Finding dividends that high is tough—even in high-dividend sectors like utilities or telecom, yields often max out at 5%. But if a company has paid a steady 5% dividend for years, you're more likely to get that than a 10% capital gain in any given year.
In tough years like 2001 or 2008, when markets dropped sharply, dividends proved more dependable. Despite long-term upward trends, those volatile periods show why bird-in-hand appeals for stability.
Disadvantages of the Bird in Hand
Warren Buffett once said that in investing, comfort rarely leads to big profits, and he's right. Sticking to dividends at around 5% per year gives you near-certain returns and security, but over the long haul, you'll likely earn less than someone focused purely on capital gains. Plus, in eras like the late 1970s, secure dividends sometimes couldn't even match inflation, leaving you with diminished real value.
Example of Bird in Hand
Take Coca-Cola (KO) as a prime example of a stock that aligns with bird-in-hand investing. The company has paid regular quarterly dividends since the 1920s and has raised them every year since 1964, offering the kind of reliable income this theory values.
Other articles for you
Engel's Law states that as household income increases, the proportion spent on food decreases while spending on other items rises.
An elevator pitch is a short speech designed to outline an idea and spark interest in a product, service, or project.
A chief financial officer oversees a company's financial operations, planning, and strategy.
A wash in investing refers to transactions that net zero gain, with complex tax rules especially for claiming losses on repurchased securities.
A fund is a pool of money set aside for specific purposes, used by individuals, businesses, and governments for various financial needs.
Jobless claims track unemployment benefit filings as a key indicator of economic health.
A Canadian Guaranteed Investment Certificate (GIC) is a low-risk, fixed-return deposit product offered by banks and trust companies, similar to U.S
Social responsibility involves individuals and companies acting ethically to benefit society and the environment while balancing profitability.
The legal rate of interest is the maximum allowable interest rate on debts to prevent excessive charges by lenders.
This text compares the Relative Strength Index (RSI) and Stochastic Oscillator as momentum indicators used to forecast market trends and identify overbought or oversold conditions.