What Is Market Timing?

Table of Contents

What Is Market Timing?

Let me tell you directly: market timing is when you move your investment money in or out of a financial market, or switch between asset classes, based on predictions. If you can forecast when the market will rise or fall, you make trades to profit from those moves. It's a core part of active management and trading strategies, using fundamental, technical, quantitative, or economic data to guide decisions. Many experts say it's impossible to time the market consistently, but some traders swear by it—though succeeding over the long term is tough.

Understanding Market Timing

You need to grasp that market timing opposes the buy-and-hold approach, where you buy securities and keep them regardless of volatility. It's feasible for pros like traders or managers who analyze charts, forecasts, and instincts to decide buy and sell times. But for the average investor like you, predicting shifts consistently to beat buy-and-hold is rare. Even buy-and-hold involves some timing due to personal needs, but the key is whether timing is central to your strategy.

Pros and Cons of Market Timing

Consider this: for everyday investors without time to monitor markets constantly, avoiding timing and focusing on long-term investing makes sense. Active folks argue you miss gains by enduring volatility instead of exiting strategically. Yet, timing entrances and exits is hard, and timers often underperform stay-invested folks. Proponents claim it yields bigger profits and cuts losses by dodging downturns, steering clear of volatile equities. But costs usually outweigh benefits—missing top market days slashes returns, as shown by studies like Dalbar's on the S&P 500 from 1995-2014, where missing 10 best days halved returns. Mutual fund timers underperform due to fees, and short-term gains face higher taxes.

Advantages and Disadvantages Summary

Advantages: Bigger profits, curtailed losses, avoidance of volatility, suited to short-term horizons.
Disadvantages: Requires daily market attention, higher transaction costs and commissions, tax-disadvantaged short-term gains, difficulty timing entrances and exits.

Criticism of Market Timing

Here's the criticism you should know: William Sharpe's 1975 study found market timers must be right 74% of the time to match a passive index fund. A 2017 Boston College study showed timing-attempting target-date funds underperformed by 0.14 percentage points, equating to 3.8% over 30 years. Morningstar research indicates only 23% of active funds beat passive ones over 10 years ending June 2019, with U.S. large-cap funds faring worst.

Market Timing FAQs

What is the Efficient Market Hypothesis? It's the idea that prices reflect all info, making consistent market-beating impossible on a risk-adjusted basis. What are some disadvantages? Daily monitoring is draining, transaction costs add up, short-term gains get higher taxes, and timing points is complex as trends shift. Who said 'time in the market, not timing the market'? Keith Banks of Bank of America in 2020. Is it really impossible? Prevailing wisdom says yes, as emotional decisions lead to underperformance. What's the biggest risk? Missing exceptional return periods by not being in the market at key times.

What Is Market Timing?

Highlights