What Is a Common-Pool Resource?
Let me explain what a common-pool resource is—it's a type of good that acts as a mix between public and private goods, shared and open to everyone but limited in supply and at risk of being overused.
Key Takeaways
- A common-pool resource combines traits of public and private goods: it's shared and non-rivalrous but scarce with a finite supply.
- These resources face the tragedy of the commons, where individuals over-consume for personal gain, depleting it for all.
- You'll see common-pool resources in environmental contexts like overfishing, water management, and air quality issues.
Understanding Common-Pool Resources
Common-pool resources have key features that align with both public and private goods. They're non-excludable, meaning you can't stop others from using them, just like public goods. But unlike public goods, they're rivalrous in consumption, similar to private goods you buy in markets—all economic goods are scarce, so we have to be careful with how we use them.
When a resource is rivalrous, consuming a unit means it's gone for others; everyone competes for it, and each use reduces the total available. For it to matter economically, it has to be scarce—non-scarce things aren't economic goods. Non-excludable means no one can block access.
This mix of non-excludability and rivalry leads to overuse and congestion. Individual interests clash with group needs, creating incentives to ignore social costs of extraction—the group pays for management, protection, and renewal. That's why these resources often fall into the tragedy of the commons, as everyone grabs the most benefit they can.
Examples of Common-Pool Resources
We typically regulate and maintain common-pool goods to keep demand from outstripping supply, ensuring they can be used ongoing. Think of forests, irrigation systems built by people, fishing areas, and underground water sources.
Take fishermen: they want to catch as many fish as possible, because if they don't, others will, leading to depleted stocks without rules. Or consider a river providing water to cities—factories might pollute it if not stopped by law, passing costs to others.
In California, high demand for surface water meets limited supplies, and without state-level groundwater management, problems worsen. During the 2012-2016 drought, farmers with old water rights used all they wanted, while cities cut back sharply.
The Tragedy of the Commons
Garrett Hardin coined the term 'tragedy of the commons' to describe issues with common-pool resources.
In his example, a herdsman grazes cattle on a shared meadow's green grass. Another sees it and does the same, then more join in. Acting in self-interest, they overgraze until no grass remains, starving all cattle.
The traits of scarcity, rivalry, and non-excludability make these resources vulnerable. Each user maximizes by taking as much as possible quickly, before others do.
No one invests in maintenance or reproduction because others can just take the benefits. The resource gets scarcer and might vanish entirely.
Common fixes include government rules and voluntary group efforts to control consumption.
Other articles for you
A parsonage allowance is a tax-exempt housing benefit provided to ministers to cover housing costs.
A Timber Investment Management Organization (TIMO) helps institutional investors manage timberland portfolios for diversification and returns.
A bridge loan provides short-term financing to bridge the gap until permanent funding is secured, often used in real estate or business for immediate cash needs.
Jan Tinbergen was a pioneering Dutch economist who won the first Nobel Prize in Economics for developing dynamic models and advancing econometrics.
Return on revenue (ROR) measures a company's profitability by comparing net income to revenue, indicating how effectively management generates profit from sales while controlling expenses.
The price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio evaluates a company's stock value by comparing its share price to earnings per share.
Kappa measures how an option's price changes with volatility shifts in the underlying asset.
Tail risk refers to the rare but significant chance of extreme investment losses that exceed normal distribution expectations.
Interbank deposits are arrangements where one bank holds funds for another to manage liquidity and meet reserve requirements.