What Is an Agency Problem?
Let me explain what an agency problem really is. It's essentially a conflict of interest that crops up in any relationship where one party— the agent—is supposed to act in the best interest of another—the principal—but ends up motivated by their own self-interest. In the world of corporate finance, this often plays out between a company's management and its stockholders. As the manager, you're acting as the agent for the shareholders, who are the principals, and you're expected to make decisions that boost shareholder wealth. But let's be real: it's often in your own best interest as the manager to focus on maximizing your personal wealth instead.
Key Takeaways
Agency problems pop up when incentives tempt an agent to ignore the principal's full best interests. Take management, for instance—they might skip actions that truly benefit shareholders. You can cut down on these problems through regulations or by setting up incentives that push the agent to align with the principal's goals.
Understanding Agency Problems
You won't see an agency problem without a clear principal-agent relationship. Here, the agent handles tasks for the principal, often because of differing skills, job roles, or limits on time and access. These issues are rampant in fiduciary setups, like between trustees and beneficiaries, board members and shareholders, or lawyers and clients. As a fiduciary, you're the agent bound to act solely in the principal's or client's best interest. This is legally strict—think of how the U.S. Supreme Court demands lawyers show complete fairness, loyalty, and fidelity to clients.
Minimizing Risks Associated With the Agency Problem
Agency costs are those internal expenses a principal faces from the agency problem, covering inefficiencies in hiring an agent and managing the relationship to resolve clashing priorities. You can't wipe out the agency problem entirely, but as a principal, you can take steps to lower the risk of these costs.
One way is through regulations. Contracts or laws often govern principal-agent ties, especially in fiduciary contexts. Consider the Fiduciary Rule—it aims to curb agency problems between financial advisors and clients by requiring advisors to prioritize client interests over their own, shielding investors from hidden conflicts.
For example, an advisor might push funds that earn them a commission, even if better options exist for the client. That's a classic agency conflict driven by financial incentives that sideline the client's needs.
Another approach is incentives. You can minimize the problem by motivating the agent to match the principal's interests. Managers might get performance-based pay, face shareholder influence, risk firing, or deal with takeover threats. Shareholders as principals can link CEO pay to stock performance. If a CEO fears a takeover could cost their job, they might block it—that's an agency issue. But tying pay to stock price aligns interests, encouraging the CEO to pursue the takeover for mutual benefit from rising shares.
You can also tweak compensation structures. If you pay an agent by project completion rather than hourly, there's less temptation to act against the principal's interests. Plus, performance reviews and independent evaluations keep agents accountable.
Real-World Example of an Agency Problem
Look at Enron in 2001—they filed for bankruptcy after executives faked accounting reports to inflate earnings and hide debt in subsidiaries. This pumped up the stock price while execs sold their shares. Shareholders lost about $74 billion over four years, and Enron's $63 billion in assets made it the biggest U.S. bankruptcy then. Management was duty-bound to shareholders, but the agency problem led them to prioritize personal gains.
What Causes an Agency Problem?
It starts in the principal-agent dynamic, like between shareholders and management. The agent might chase self-interest over the principal's, such as enriching themselves instead of boosting shareholder value.
What Is an Example of an Agency Problem?
Enron's 2001 bankruptcy is a prime case—management ignored shareholder interests for their own due to the agency problem.
How Can You Mitigate Agency Problems?
You can't eliminate them, but minimize risks—called agency costs—through contracts, laws for fiduciaries, or incentives. Paying by project, not hours, reduces temptations to stray from the principal's interests.
The Bottom Line
Agency problems stem from incentive issues and discretion in tasks. An agent might act against the principal if incentives encourage it. Say you hire a plumber as agent to fix pipes—they could recommend unneeded work for triple pay, creating the problem through that incentive.
Other articles for you
A not-held order lets brokers use their discretion on timing and price to get the best fill without being liable for any misses.
A long position involves buying an asset expecting its price to rise for potential profit.
An escrow agreement is a contract that uses a third-party agent to hold assets securely until transaction conditions are met, ensuring trust in high-value deals like real estate.
A loan constant is a percentage representing the annual debt service relative to the total principal of a fixed-rate loan, aiding borrowers in comparing loan costs.
A golden handshake is a substantial severance package provided to executives upon job loss, often criticized for rewarding failure.
Deferred annuities are insurance contracts that grow tax-deferred and provide future income after an accumulation period.
EBIAT is a non-GAAP metric that measures a company's profitability after taxes but before interest, providing insights into cash available for debt repayment.
An annuity due requires payments at the beginning of each period, differing from ordinary annuities paid at the end, with examples like rent and calculations adjusting for timing.
Operating activities are the core business functions that generate a company's primary cash flow and profitability through producing and selling goods or services.
Real GDP is an inflation-adjusted measure of a country's economic output, contrasting with nominal GDP which uses current prices.