What Is Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)?

Table of Contents

What Is Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)?

Let me explain what Import Substitution Industrialization, or ISI, really is. It's an economic strategy that developing nations use to cut down on their dependence on developed countries by building up their own industries. This approach was big in the 20th century, aiming for self-sufficient economies. It worked well at first, but ran into problems later on, pushing countries toward more market-oriented policies.

Key Takeaways on ISI

You should know that ISI is all about developing countries fostering their own industries to stand up against imported goods and achieve self-sufficiency. They do this with tariffs, import quotas, and government loans to shield and expand local production. This clashes with the idea of comparative advantage, where countries specialize in what they do best and trade internationally. ISI was popular in the 20th century, especially in Latin America, but by the 1980s and 1990s, economic issues led many to abandon it. It's tied to structuralist economics, which looks at a country's unique political, social, and institutional setup for development.

How Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI) Works

The core of ISI is to protect, strengthen, and expand local industries. You achieve this through tactics like tariffs, import quotas, and subsidized government loans. When countries apply ISI, they work to secure every stage of a product's production chain domestically. Keep in mind, this goes against the comparative advantage principle, where nations specialize in low-cost production and export those goods.

A Historical Overview of Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)

ISI might seem like a 20th-century idea, but its roots go back to the 18th century, with economists like Alexander Hamilton and Friedrich List pushing for it. Countries in Latin America, Africa, and parts of Asia adopted ISI to create self-sufficiency through internal markets. They subsidized key sectors like power and agriculture, and used nationalization and protectionism to make it work. But starting in the 1980s and 1990s, developing nations started ditching ISI because of global market liberalization and pressure from the IMF and World Bank for structural adjustments.

Key Economic Theories Behind Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)

ISI draws from several developmental policies, built on the infant industry argument, the Singer-Prebisch thesis, and Keynesian economics. From these, you get practices like an industrial policy that subsidizes strategic substitutes, trade barriers such as tariffs, an overvalued currency to help importers of goods for manufacturing, and little encouragement for foreign direct investment. Closely linked is structuralist economics, developed by thinkers like Hans Singer, Celso Furtado, and Octavio Paz, which stresses considering a country's political, social, and institutional structures in economic analysis. A key point is the dependency emerging countries have on developed ones. This school gained traction through the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America (ECLA or CEPAL), and Latin American structuralism essentially defined the ISI era from the 1950s to the 1980s.

Case Studies: Successful Applications of Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)

The ECLA was established in 1950, with Raul Prebisch as executive secretary, and he laid out a vision for Latin America's shift from export-led growth to internal industrial development in a key report that became the blueprint for ISI. Following this, countries like Argentina, Brazil, and Mexico adopted ISI and started producing advanced goods such as machinery, electronics, and aircraft at home. It had successes, but also caused high inflation and other issues. By the 1970s, stagnation and debt crises forced many to take loans from the IMF and World Bank, which required dropping protectionist policies and opening to free trade.

How Does a Tariff Work?

A tariff acts like a tax on imports—either a flat fee per item or a percentage of its value. You'll see them in international trade to protect domestic producers and the overall economy.

What Are Some Examples of a Protectionist Trade Policy?

Protectionist trade policies are rules that restrict or block international trade. Tariffs are a classic example, along with import quotas that cap the amount of products a country can bring in.

What Are Keynesian Economics?

Keynesian economics comes from John Maynard Keynes, who argued that people saving more during recessions hurts the economy further. He noted that cutting interest rates doesn't always boost demand, and crucially, that government spending is key to pulling an economy out of tough times.

The Bottom Line

In summary, ISI is an economic policy that developing nations used to build self-sufficiency by growing domestic industries to rival imports, using tariffs, quotas, and subsidies to lessen reliance on developed countries. But with the push for market liberalization in the 1980s and 1990s, and problems like inflation and stagnation, it fell out of favor. It did help establish local industries initially, yet its challenges led to its decline. If you're looking at industrial and trade policies, studying ISI's history provides solid lessons.

What Is Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI)?

Highlights