Table of Contents
What Is the Labor Theory of Value?
Let me explain the labor theory of value to you directly. This economic theory, introduced by thinkers like Adam Smith and David Ricardo, holds that a commodity's value comes from the labor hours required to produce it. Even though it's been largely replaced by the subjective theory of value, it shaped economic ideas significantly and influenced Karl Marx.
Key Takeaways
Here's what you need to know about the labor theory of value. It proposes that a commodity's value is set by the average labor time needed for production. Economists such as Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and Karl Marx championed this in the 18th and 19th centuries. Eventually, it gave way to the subjective theory, which ties value to individual views of usefulness. Critics point out issues like goods with identical labor but varying market values, or those without demand. Marx built on it to argue that capitalist profits stem from underpaying workers for their labor's true value.
In-Depth Look at the Labor Theory of Value
Diving deeper, the labor theory suggests that two commodities trade at the same price if they require the same labor time, or they exchange based on the ratio of their labor times. For example, if hunting a deer takes 20 hours and trapping a beaver takes 10, you'd trade two beavers for one deer.
This idea originated with ancient Greek and medieval philosophers. Smith and Ricardo developed it by imagining a simple society of self-producers without classes or modern capital. In this setup, everyone owns their tools, and incomes depend on labor time. Smith saw labor as the original exchange medium, so more labor means greater relative value.
Ricardo focused on how relative prices are governed. Using the beaver-deer example, if one beaver needs 20 hours (including making a trap) and one deer needs 10, the exchange is one beaver for two deer. This includes vertically integrated labor—direct hunting plus indirect tool-making.
Practical Example of Labor Theory of Value
Consider this practical scenario. Initially, beaver production is more profitable than deer. Producing a beaver takes 20 hours (12 for trap, 8 for hunt) at $11 per hour, yielding $220 income and $220 cost. Deer takes 10 hours (4 for bow and arrow, 6 for hunt) at $9 per hour, yielding $180 income but $90 cost.
People shift to beaver production, causing equilibration. The labor time suggests a 2:1 ratio. Beaver income drops to $10 per hour ($200 for 20 hours, $200 cost), deer rises to $10 per hour ($200 for 20 hours equivalent, $100 cost). This natural price aligns due to arbitrage.
Market prices fluctuate with supply and demand, but they gravitate toward this natural price set by labor. High prices encourage more production, low ones encourage buying, balancing out over time. That's how labor determines value and prices.
How Marxism Utilizes the Labor Theory of Value
Marx wove the labor theory into his entire analysis in Das Kapital, focusing on tensions between capitalists and workers. He insisted value comes from socially necessary labor, not just any labor. This allowed him to critique free-market economists: if values are labor-based and goods sell at true value, profits must come from underpaying workers, leading to his exploitation theory.
Criticisms and Limitations of the Labor Theory of Value
The theory has flaws. You could spend lots of labor on something worthless, but the theory requires commodities to have use-value, exchange-value, and reproducibility—excluding art or useless items. Socially necessary labor addresses varying production times.
Another issue: similar labor times yield different prices, and prices fluctuate without stable ratios, contradicting the theory. But remember, market price differs from value; prices signal supply and demand, tending toward value over time.
The Rise of the Subjective Theory Over Labor Theory
The subjective theory resolved these by basing value on personal judgments of usefulness. People produce goods because they value them, reversing the labor theory: usefulness drives labor expenditure, not vice versa.
Developed by medieval Scholastics like Aquinas, it was rediscovered in the 1870s by Jevons, Walras, and Menger, sparking the Subjectivist Revolution.
The Bottom Line
To wrap up, the labor theory asserts goods' value derives from production labor, backed by Smith, Ricardo, and Marx. It's been overtaken by the subjective theory, which focuses on perceived usefulness. This shift highlights how economic thought evolved from labor-centric to preference-based valuation, explaining price dynamics through supply, demand, and human judgment.
Other articles for you
A voting trust agreement allows shareholders to transfer their voting rights to a trustee for temporary corporate control.
Unlimited risk in trading and investing means potential for unlimited losses, but it can be managed through strategies like hedging and stop losses.
Tax planning is about analyzing finances to minimize taxes through strategies like retirement contributions and gain-loss harvesting.
Bank deposits are funds placed in bank accounts for safekeeping, offering security, accessibility, and potential interest.
Voting shares allow stockholders to vote on corporate policies and decisions like board elections and mergers.
A limit order book is a record of outstanding limit orders for securities maintained by exchange specialists.
The New Zealand Dollar (NZD) is the official currency of New Zealand and several territories, with a history of evolution from British systems to a floating exchange rate and modern polymer notes.
Assemble-to-order (ATO) is a production strategy that quickly assembles customizable products from pre-manufactured parts upon receiving customer orders.
M2 is the Federal Reserve's measure of the U.S
Inherent risk refers to the natural susceptibility of financial statements to material misstatements due to factors like transaction complexity and accounting judgments, independent of internal controls.