What Is a Holdover Tenant?
Let me explain what a holdover tenant is: you're dealing with a renter who sticks around in the property after the lease has run out. If I, as the landlord, keep accepting your rent payments, you can legally stay put, and it's up to state laws and court decisions to figure out how long this new rental period lasts. But if I stop taking your rent, you're basically trespassing, and if you don't leave right away, I'll have to go through eviction to get you out.
Key Takeaways on Holdover Tenants
You need to know that a holdover tenant is someone who keeps paying rent even after the lease expires, but only if the landlord agrees to it—otherwise, eviction might be on the table. This situation sits in a tricky spot between a proper rental agreement and outright trespassing. Even something as basic as a one-sentence agreement gives everyone more protection, so consider it seriously. Often, this whole issue gets avoided thanks to the month-to-month clause in most rental contracts.
Understanding Holdover Tenants
If you're a landlord like me, you want to steer clear of accidentally ending up with a holdover tenant, so always put a clause in the original lease that spells out what happens when the lease ends—this protects your property and your rights. For instance, a one-year apartment lease might say it turns into a month-to-month deal once it expires.
When I accept rent from a holdover tenant, the rules change depending on state and local laws. Sometimes, taking that payment resets the whole lease term—for example, if the original was for a year, accepting rent after expiration starts a fresh year-long lease. In other places, it just kicks off a month-to-month arrangement.
To get a tenant out, I have to start a holdover proceeding, which is basically an eviction case not tied to missed rent—it's handled in eviction or small claims courts.
Important Note for Landlords
If you want a holdover tenant gone, don't accept any rent from them and treat them as a trespasser—that's crucial.
Holdover Tenant Rights
As a holdover tenant, you have what's called a tenancy at sufferance. 'Sufferance' here means there's no real objection but no genuine approval either, and it's the flip side of a tenancy-at-will, where you occupy the place with the owner's consent but usually without a written lease. Tenancy at sufferance applies to holdover tenants from an expired lease who don't have the landlord's permission to stay but haven't been evicted yet.
When a landlord wants to evict you as a holdover tenant, they usually have to serve you with a notice of termination, but this varies by state. That notice starts the holdover proceeding. Take New York State as an example: a notice of termination is required if your lease ended but the landlord took rent afterward, or if you have no written lease but pay monthly rent, or if the landlord wants you out before the lease is up, or if you're in rent-regulated housing, or have a Section 8 subsidy, or if your lease demands it.
Details in the Notice of Termination
- The notice has to state the reason for termination, the date you must move out, and that legal action will follow if you don't comply by then.
- Reasons might include lease expiration, bad tenant behavior like being too noisy or having an unapproved pet, being a subtenant without landlord knowledge, squatting by moving in without permission, unreasonably blocking landlord access, or making unapproved changes like adding a wall.
Exceptions to Notice Requirements
That said, you're not entitled to a notice of termination if your lease expired and you've stayed without paying rent—in that scenario, the landlord can jump straight to a holdover proceeding without any notice.
Other articles for you
A registered representative is a licensed financial professional who handles client securities transactions and must adhere to regulatory standards.
This page offers resources for analyzing sectors and industries to identify top companies and investment opportunities.
Discounting determines the present value of future payments by factoring in time value of money and risk.
Disruptive innovation transforms expensive or complex products into affordable, accessible options that disrupt established markets.
A discretionary order allows brokers some flexibility in executing trades on behalf of clients without needing approval for every detail.
A deposition is sworn testimony taken outside court during the discovery phase of a lawsuit to gather evidence and prepare for trial.
Bid and ask prices represent the highest amount buyers will pay and the lowest sellers will accept for stocks, with the spread indicating liquidity and market maker profits.
Form 1095-B is an IRS document that reports health insurance coverage details for taxpayers under the Affordable Care Act.
An option pool reserves company shares for employees to attract talent in startups, often diluting founders' ownership through investor demands.
The Nasdaq 100 Index tracks the 100 largest nonfinancial companies on the Nasdaq exchange using a modified market cap weighting for balanced exposure across sectors.