Table of Contents
- What Is Value Engineering?
- Key Takeaways
- Understanding Value Engineering
- Ratio of Function to Cost
- Steps in Value Engineering
- Guiding Principles of Value Engineering
- Types of Value
- Value Engineering Tools
- Value Engineering vs. Value Analysis
- Limitations of Value Engineering
- Example of Value Engineering
- The Bottom Line
What Is Value Engineering?
Let me tell you directly: value engineering is a systematic, organized approach to delivering the necessary functions in a project at the lowest possible cost. I see it as promoting the substitution of materials and methods with cheaper alternatives, all without sacrificing functionality. You should know it's focused purely on the functions of components and materials, not their physical attributes. Sometimes it's called value analysis, but that's the core of it.
Key Takeaways
Here's what you need to grasp: value engineering provides necessary project functions at the lowest cost through a systematic approach. It encourages using less expensive materials and methods while keeping functionality intact. The process often breaks into six steps, from idea generation to implementing changes. It emphasizes use, cost, esteem, and exchange values. Ultimately, value is function divided by cost, and value engineering maximizes function while cutting costs.
Understanding Value Engineering
When I look at value engineering, it's about reviewing new or existing products in the design phase to cut costs and boost functionality, thereby increasing the product's value. You define an item's value as the most cost-effective way to produce it without undermining its purpose. Cutting costs by skimping on quality? That's just cost-cutting, not value engineering. The concept started in the 1940s at General Electric during World War II. Engineers like Lawrence Miles hunted for substitutes due to shortages, and those often reduced costs while maintaining or improving performance. Remember, cost reduction in value engineering must not affect product quality.
Ratio of Function to Cost
Lawrence Miles defined product value as the ratio of function to cost. Function is the specific work the item performs, and cost covers its entire life cycle, including production, design, maintenance, and replacement. This ratio means you can increase value by improving function or decreasing cost. For instance, if a tech product lasts only two years, design it with the cheapest materials that hold up for that period—it saves money for everyone. Another approach is maximizing function at minimal cost by analyzing each component's purpose and exploring alternatives.
Steps in Value Engineering
Value engineering typically follows six steps, though they might vary slightly by organization. You start with gathering information, analyzing the product's lifecycle, including spending, processes, and resources. Break it down into manageable data like financial values, priorities, time, and labor. Next, think creatively: reimagine development with new approaches, risks, or innovative applications. Brainstorm freely—change materials, designs, features, or processes. Then evaluate ideas, weighing pros and cons carefully; a big disadvantage might outweigh multiple benefits. Develop and analyze the best ideas: draft plans, detail impacts, revise projections, and check viability, considering timelines and break-even points. Present discoveries to management with fair comparisons, focusing on benefits, timelines, projections, and risks. Finally, implement changes: form teams, oversee adjustments, and monitor alignment with expectations. If expertise is lacking, outsource the early steps.
Guiding Principles of Value Engineering
No matter the steps, certain principles guide value engineering. It takes a function-oriented approach, shifting focus from physical attributes to purpose. You perform cost-worth analysis, examining costs against value and removing low-benefit functions. Team collaboration is key, bringing in experts from engineering, design, manufacturing, and finance for comprehensive insights. Stay client-centric with regular feedback to align solutions with what clients value. And document everything—methodologies, analyses, decisions—for future efficiency.
Types of Value
In value engineering, you consider four main types of value, though perceptions vary. Use value comes from the product's attributes and purpose—without it, the product fails. Cost value involves production expenses; if costs exceed perceived value, rebalance is needed. Esteem value is intrinsic, like brand recognition, which can be positive or negative depending on the consumer. Exchange value relates to how easily the product can be bought or traded, affected by distribution and characteristics. Ultimately, value engineering captures all perceived customer values.
Value Engineering Tools
Companies pick tools as needed for value engineering. Function Analysis System Technique (FAST) visualizes function relationships to identify efficiencies. Brainstorming generates innovative ideas without judgment. Benchmarking compares against industry standards for targets. Life Cycle Cost Analysis evaluates total ownership costs for long-term decisions. Value Stream Mapping identifies waste in processes. Design of Experiments tests variables statistically. Pareto Analysis prioritizes significant factors. The Function-Cost Matrix highlights cost-saving opportunities by comparing functions and costs.
Value Engineering vs. Value Analysis
Value engineering applies before fabrication to prevent value loss, while value analysis reviews existing products to enhance value. Value engineering aids manufacturing; value analysis might focus on business or sales. They're similar but distinct: engineering prevents issues, analysis fixes them.
Limitations of Value Engineering
Value engineering demands time for data gathering, meetings, and documentation, with no guaranteed success. It can favor short-term savings over long-term value, leading to higher future costs. Excessive cost focus might reduce appeal or cause over-engineering. It's not always applicable due to regulations, client preferences, or lack of resources.
Example of Value Engineering
Take the Golden Gate Bridge: initial costs were too high during the Great Depression. Engineers used value engineering to substitute materials, simplify designs, and innovate techniques, cutting costs from $100 million to $35 million while meeting all functions.
The Bottom Line
Value engineering ensures products maximize potential by evaluating functions, creating value, and minimizing costs. Without it, products lose market place and become unprofitable.
Other articles for you
A gray market involves unofficial trading of securities or unauthorized imports of goods, offering insights and discounts but with risks like unfulfilled trades and lack of support.
An investment fund pools capital from multiple investors to buy securities, offering diversification and professional management.
A ground lease allows a tenant to develop land for a long term before returning it and all improvements to the owner.
An impaired asset is a company asset that has declined in value below its original cost, requiring accurate financial reporting to reflect true worth.
New Keynesian economics updates classical Keynesian ideas by emphasizing sticky prices and wages, explaining unemployment and the role of monetary policy.
Systemic risk is the potential for a company-level event to trigger widespread instability or collapse in an industry or economy, as seen in the 2008 financial crisis.
A unilateral transfer is a one-way payment of money, goods, or services without any expectation of reciprocation from the recipient.
Unlimited liability means business owners fully bear all company debts, risking their personal assets.
Value investing focuses on buying undervalued stocks based on their intrinsic worth for long-term profits.
The PATH Act of 2015 renewed and expanded tax credits while adding fraud prevention measures.